Artículo de revisión
Vol. 46 Núm. 3 (2026)
29 min
Lora Sri NOFI1, RIMBAWAN1, Evy DAMAYANTHI1, SUSETYOWATI2
1 Faculty of Medicine and Nutrition, IPB University, Bogor, Indonesia.
2 Faculty of Medicine, Public Health, and Nursing, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Yogyakarta, Indonesia.
Cómo citar
Métricas
165
Visualizaciones
24
Descargas
Compartir
Compartir
Resumen (EN)
Background: Malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients remains a significant clinical problem and is associated with increased risk of complications, prolonged hospital stay, impaired functional status, and poor health outcomes. Accurate assessment of malnutrition is essential; however, variability in assessment methods and tools may affect diagnostic accuracy and clinical decision-making.
Goal: This study aimed to systematically review the methods and or assessment tools of malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients.
Methods: A systematic literature review was conducted following PRISMA 2020 guidelines and registered in PROSPERO (CRD420251037218). Literature searches were performed across six databases: PubMed, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, MDPI, Hindawi, and Wiley, covering publications from 2015 to 2024. Study selection was based on PICOS criteria. Screening and data extraction were conducted independently by two reviewers. The findings were synthesized narratively.
Results: A total of 23 studies involving 79,691 paediatric patients were included. A narrative approach was used instead of a meta-analysis due to diverse methodologies. The prevalence of malnutrition ranged from 12.6% to 70%, depending on study populations and assessment methods. Anthropometric measurements were the most commonly used methods and were associated with clinical outcomes; however, their accuracy was limited in conditions affecting body composition. Functional assessments and biochemical markers provided additional insights but were not consistently applied. Among validated tools, the Subjective Global Nutri tional Assessment (SGNA) demonstrated the association with clinical outcomes such as complications, readmission, and survival. Overall, a combined assessment approach provided a more comprehensive evaluation of malnutrition.
Conclusion: No single method is sufficient to assess malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients. A multidimensional approach integrating anthropometric, clinical, functional, and biochemical indicators is recommended to improve diagnostic accuracy and clinical outcomes.
Palabras clave (EN):
Introduction
Malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients is a complex clinical problem that significantly impacts the healing process, increasing the risk of infectious complications, decreasing physical function, length of stay, and short- and long-term health outcomes. Malnutrition is caused not only by inadequate nutrient intake but also by disease severity, including inflammation, gastrointestinal dysfunction, and side effects of medical therapy. According to various studies in Europe and the United States, the prevalence of malnutrition in paediatric based on anthropometric measurements upon hospital admission is 7.1-39.7%1. According to Dia manti et al.2 in Italy, the prevalence of malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients with chronic diseases is 56.7% inpatient and 33.3% outpatient. In hospitals in Indonesia, the prevalence of malnutrition in paediatric cancer patients reaches 40.2%1. These data indicate that the prevalence of malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients is relatively high. Therefore, accurate assessment of malnutrition status is crucial for establishing a nutritional diagnosis, determining effective nutritional interventions, and serving as an indicator of success through monitoring and evaluation of the nutritional care process.
Malnutrition status assessments conducted by dietitians and nutritionists aim to establish a diagnosis of malnutrition in patients so that nutritional interventions can be planned1. Identifying malnutrition status is also crucial for dietitians and nutritionists to determine the timeframe for monitoring, evaluation, and reassessment. Evaluations by dietitians and nutritionists indicate better fulfilment of nutritional needs1.
Currently, several methods and assesment tools for assessing paediatric malnutrition are used in hospitals. Assess ment methods include anthropometric and biochemical data, clinical physical examination, and dietary history. Several methods for assessing malnutrition status are based on anthropometry, such as mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) and handgrip strength3, biochemical tests such as haemo glo bin, C-Reactive Protein (CRP), and white blood cell counts4, physical examination data such as muscle mass and fat mass and other clinical conditions4, and dietary history, assessed by a decrease in food intake of approximately 50% or more over a certain period5. AND/ASPEN Indicators of Malnutrition in Paediatrics (AAIMPtool), a consensus tool of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (AND) and the American Society of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition (ASPEN), and the Subjective Global Nutritional Assessment (SGNA), a validated instrument6. Each method and instrument has its own advantages and disadvantages, including being time-consuming, lacking specificity, and prone to multiple perceptions depending on the ability and expertise of the dietitian/nutritionist performing the assessment7.
In healthcare practice, the success of nutritional care for paediatric patients is crucially determined by the identification and confirmation of malnutrition early in treatment. This process also serves as the foundation for planning nutritional interventions, monitoring therapeutic response, and evaluating nutritional care outcomes. Therefore, an accurate, comprehensive, and applicable assessment of malnutrition status is an essential component of paediatric nutrition services in hospitals. The SLR was conducted with the aim of comprehensively identifying the methods and instrument tools used to assess malnutrition status in paediatric patients in hospitals.
Methods
The systematic literature review (SLR) development process begins with formulating a research question. This question is specific and uses the PICOS (Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, and Study Design) approach to ensure a clear focus. This was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) 2020 guidelines to ensure methodological rigor, transparency, and reproducibility. The review protocol was prospectively registered in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) (Registration No: CRD420251037218).
The population included hospitalized paediatric patients aged 1 month to 18 years. The intervention consisted of various tools and methods used to assess paediatric malnutrition in hospital settings. The methods and assessment tools of paediatric malnutrition were being compared. Outcomes of interest included malnutrition status, prevalence, and clinical outcomes such as complications, length of hospital stay, and readmission. Eligible study designs included observational studies; prospective cohort, retrospective cohort and cross-sectional, published in English between 1 Januari 2015 and 31 December 2024. Studies were limited for methods and or assessment tools for paediatric malnutrition. Studies also excluded if had insufficient data and had fewer than 25 subjects.
A comprehensive literature search was conducted across six electronic databases: PubMed, ScienceDirect, Springer Link, MDPI, Hindawi, and Wiley. The search strategy was developed using Boolean operators and combinations of the following keywords: “paediatric,” “hospital,” “malnutrition assessment,” “nutritional status,” and “SGNA. The search strategy was adapted for each database using controlled vocabulary (e.g., MeSH terms) and free-text keywords; (paediatric) AND (hospital) AND (malnutrition assessment OR nutritional status OR SGNA). The search results were then uploaded to the Rayyan platform in file formats such as RIS or BibTeX. Rayyan accelerated the literature selection process thanks to its artificial intelligence features. After the literature was selected, data extraction was performed, recording key information such as methods, populations, and research results.
The study selection process followed the PRISMA flow, consisting of identification, screening, eligibility, and inclusion stages. Titles and abstracts were screened independently by two reviewers based on predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria, followed by full-text assessment for eligibility. Rayyan accelerated the literature selection process thanks to its artificial intelligence features. Discrepancies were resolved through discussion between the two reviewers to reach consensus and agreement of the literature selection. If discrepancies occured, the decision was settled by the first author as one of the reviewer.
Data extraction was conducted independently by two reviewers using a standardized form to ensure consistency and completeness. Extracted data included study characteristics (author, year, country, study design, and sample size), population characteristics, malnutrition assessment methods, prevalence of malnutrition, and clinical outcomes. The next stage was data analysis and synthesis, identifying patterns or research gaps. Due to heterogeneity in study designs, number of populations, pathology or disease aetiology, wide range of subjects’ age, paediatric malnutrition assessment methods and tools, clinical and cut off points, a meta-analysis was not performed. A narrative synthesis approach was used to summarize findings, compare assessment methods, and identify patterns across studies. These results were presented in summary tables or data visualizations to facilitate interpretation. The final stage was writing and reporting the results.
The assessment of methodological quality and potential risk of bias for the studies was conducted using a checklist based on the Consensus-based Standards for the Selection of Health Measurement Instruments (COSMIN) approach. The evaluation focused on six key domains reflecting the measurement properties of paediatric malnutrition assessment instruments: content validity, construct validity, reliability (including internal consistency), measurement error, and responsiveness. The risk-of-bias assessment results are presented visually using the RobVis tool to provide a comprehensive and easily interpretable overview, particularly regarding the methodological quality of each study.
Result
A total of 671 records were identified through database searching. After removing 41 duplicate records, 630 records underwent title and abstract screening. Of these, 23 reports were retrieved and assessed for full-text eligibility. All 23 studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in the final review. The study selection process is illustrated in Figure 1. The included studies were conducted across North America, South America, Africa, Asia, Australia, and Europe. Four studies were conducted in the United States, two in Canada, five in South America, four in Africa (Tanzania, Ethiopia, Egypt, and Nigeria), six in Asia (Bangladesh, Malaysia, Thailand, India, and Saudi Arabia), one in Australia, and one in Europe (Scotland). Across the 23 included studies, a total of 79,691 paediatric patients were evaluated. Of these, 75,273 participants were included in six retrospective cohort studies, 3,607 in eleven prospective or prospective cohort studies, and 811 in six cross-sectional studies. Participants ranged in age from 1 month to 18 years and represented diverse clinical populations, including children with cancer, HIV/AIDS, neurodevelopmental disorders, gastrointestinal surgery, elective surgery, and Crohn’s disease. The characteristics of the included studies are summarized (Table 1 and Table 2). The methodological quality and risk of bias of the included studies were assessed using the COSMIN Risk of Bias framework. Overall, the included studies demonstrated varying levels of methodological quality across the six assessed domains. While most studies showed a low overall risk of bias, several studies presented unclear or high risk of bias in specific methodological domains.
The prevalence of malnutrition varied across the included studies, ranging from 12.6% to 70%. Based on anthropometric indicators, the reported prevalence ranged from 47.8% to 67% for weight-for-age, 36% to 69.9% for height-for-age, and 24% to 69.9% for body mass index-for-age, WHO Z-Score 36.2% to 67% and MUAC for age 25% to 45%. The prevalence of malnutrition using validated tools or instruments is 34.7% to 70%. Using validated clinical tools, the prevalence ranged from 34.7% to 70% across different study populations.
Anthropometric measurements were the most frequently utilized assessment approach across studies. The assessment utilizes anthropometric data such as mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC), anthropometric indices such as weight for age, height for age, weight for height, and body mass for age, including the Z-score or percentile. A cross multiple studies, these indicators were associated with clinical outcomes such as length of hospital stay, complications, and mortality. Variability in findings was reported in clinical conditions characterized by fluid imbalance, organomegaly, and tumour burden, which may influence body weight measurements. Among anthropometric indicators, MUAC demonstrated consistent associations with clinical outcomes across different study populations and clinical settings. However, few studies reported contrary findings for MUAC significancy in Ethiopia, India and Brazil.
The physical examination used in assessing malnutrition status in the SLR is derived from the results of a Nutrition Focused Physical Examination (NFPE), which includes muscle mass, Hand Grip Strength (HGS) measurements, hair, skin, mouth, nails, signs of fluid retention or dehydration, and other conditions. HGS was associated with reduced muscle function and inflammatory markers, while NFPE findings showed agreement with validated assessment tools across multiple studies. Biochemical blood tests include C-Reactive Protein (CRP), a marker of inflammation, infection, or tissue damage. Biochemical markers, particularly C-Reactive Protein (CRP), were used to reflect inflammatory status, although their application was not uniform across studies.
Several validated assessment tools were identified, including the Subjective Global Nutritional Assessment (SGNA), AAIMPtool, and ANPEDCancer. SGNA was the most consistently applied tool and was associated with clinically relevant outcomes, including complications, readmission, and survival across different study populations. AAIMPtool demonstrated moderate agreement with SGNA and other assessment methods, while ANPEDCancer was primarily applied in paediatric oncology populations.
Discussion
This SLR aimed to systematically review the methods and or assessment tools of malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients. The literature indicates that paediatric malnutrition remains a significant clinical problem with a high prevalence. This adverse clinical outcomes, requiring continuous attention and intervention. Paediatric population (1 month-18 years) is vulnerable to malnutrition, especially in chronic and postoperative conditions1,28. This review provides comprehensive evidence on malnutrition status to support nutritional intervention planning and clinical outcome monitoring. The literature synthesis identified five key concepts for malnutrition assessment: anthropometry, classification, clinical manifestations, physiological imbalance mechanisms, and outcome evaluation, offering a more comprehensive understanding than reliance on a single indicator5. This study considered diverse paediatric populations with various medical conditions, including chronic and neurological diseases10. Comparing different assessment methods may help identify the most appropriate tools for evaluating malnutrition. This approach is supported by previous studies demonstrating the association between malnutrition and clinical outcomes, such as length of hospital stay, infections, and mortality29. Therefore, this SLR provides a strong scientific basis for developing valid malnutrition assessment tools and improving the quality of paediatric nutritional care30.
In order to illustrate the literature search and selection process systematically, the study identification flow in this SLR is presented using the PRISMA diagram approach. This diagram shows the stages of study selection, starting from the initial identification of articles through electronic databases, the duplication removal process, title and abstract screening, full-text eligibility assessment, and determining the number of studies that meet the inclusion criteria and are included in the final synthesis. This process ensures transparency and traceability of the literature selection process, while minimizing potential bias in study selection. The PRISMA flow diagram also provides a quantitative overview of the number of articles eliminated at each stage and the reasons for their exclusion, thereby strengthening the methodological quality and reproducibility of the LSR results. The PRISMA flowchart systematically illustrates the process of identifying, screening, and selecting studies in this SLR. During the identification stage, 671 articles were obtained through searches of six electronic databases. This number reflects the breadth of the literature search to ensure that all relevant scientific evidence related to malnutrition assessment in hospitalized paediatric patients was comprehensively identified. This approach aligns with the SLR principle, which emphasizes a broad and systematic literature search to minimize the risk of publication bias30. The study selection flow based on the PRISMA guidelines is presented in Figure 1.
In the pre-screening stage, 41 articles were removed from duplication, leaving 630 articles for the title and abstract screening stage. The duplication removal process is a crucial step in SLR to avoid bias due to double-counting of the same publication and to improve the efficiency of the selection process (Page et al., 2021). Furthermore, during the screening stage, several articles were excluded due to non-fulfilment of inclusion criteria, particularly related to inappropriate research designs, irrelevant populations, outdated publications, limited full-text access, and language differences. The title and abstract screening process was conducted using the Rayyan application, a reference management platform for systematic reviews. Using Rayyan allows for a more efficient, structured, and transparent article selection process, while minimizing selection errors through systematic inclusion-exclusion marking. Furthermore, Rayyan assists researchers in consistently documenting the reasons for article exclusion throughout the literature screening process. After the screening process, 23 articles were deemed suitable for further review and were subjected to a full -text assessment. This stage aimed to ensure the methodological and substantive suitability of the articles’ content to the study focus established in the PICOS approach. All articles evaluated at this stage met the inclusion criteria, and no reports were excluded, thus all were included in the final SLR synthesis.
Overall, this PRISMA diagram demonstrates that the study selection process was rigorous, transparent, and structured, in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Sys tema tic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) 2020 guidelines (Page et al., 2021). The significant reduction in the number of articles from the identification to inclusion stage reflects the application of specific inclusion and exclusion criteria and the targeted focus of the studies. Therefore, the included studies had high methodological and clinical relevance, allowing the synthesis results to serve as a strong conceptual and empirical foundation. The SLR results are presented in Table 1, which summarizes the main characteristics of the included studies. This table provides a comprehensive overview of the year and location of the study, the design and sample size, population characteristics, the nutritional assessment tools or methods used, and the main findings and clinical significance of each study.
The SLR results indicate that the approach to malnutrition assessment in paediatric patients is still dominated by the use of anthropometric methods, either as a single method or as a component in a multidimensional assessment instrument. This dominant use of anthropometry also reflects the availability of data and ease of implementation in various healthcare settings, especially in paediatric patients2. Anthropo metric indices such as weight for age, height for age, weight for height, body mass index (BMI/A), WHO Z Score, MUAC, and MUAC/A are widely used because they are objective, relatively easy to implement, low cost, and have a strong epidemiological basis for monitoring the nutritional status of the paediatric population (WHO, 2006). Anthropometric indices such as weight for age, height for age, and body mass index (BMI/A) can be considered relatively effective in identifying malnutrition status in paediatric patients10, especially acute malnutrition18. This can be assumed because there is a significant relationship (p<0.001) between BB/H and BMI/A in identifying acute malnutrition26. The effectiveness of anthropometric methods in determining malnutrition status is also conveyed in the SLR related to prediction of indicators such as complications, length of stay (LOS), and outcomes. The anthropometric index of BB/A and BB/H can predict the occurrence of complications19, BMI/A is statistically significantly correlated with complications and length of stay20,23, TB/A is a significant predictor of worsening outcomes20, such as in paediatric HIV/AIDS patients12, even to death27. In terms of the sensitivity of malnutrition prediction, the SLR also found that assessment using the Z-score was superior to assessment using percentiles17. This is likely because assessment using the Z-score uses range data, while percentiles use definitive data.
However, the literature consistently shows that anthropometric assessment of malnutrition in paediatric has significant limitations in validly determining malnutrition status. One study on SLR demonstrating this is the use of the WHO Z-Score in paediatric patients undergoing elective surgery in Ethiopia. The study found no significant association between malnutrition and infection and length of stay (LOS)14. This may be due to various medical and/or non-nutritional conditions such as oedema, fluid overload, dehydration, hepatosplenomegaly or organomegaly, and tumour mass, which can distort weight measurements and their derivatives, potentially leading to misclassification of nutritional status4, including malnutrition assessment. This finding is particularly relevant in paediatric patients with chronic diseases and malignancies, where changes in body composition, such as loss of muscle and fat mass, are not always accurately reflected by conventional anthropometric indicators. Therefore, the use of anthropometry as the sole basis for determining nutritional status and/or malnutrition status risks causing underdiagnosis of malnutrition status in hospitalized paediatric patients.
Among the anthropometric indicators studied, mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) emerged as the most consistent and feasible indicator across studies. MUAC has been reported to be significantly associated with length of hospital stay, inflammatory markers, and poorer clinical outcomes, particularly in paediatric under five years of age and patients with certain medical conditions4. The advantages of MUAC lie in its ease of measurement, its relative resistance to distortion due to changes in fluid status compared to body weight, its ability to reflect muscle and fat reserves, and its concordance with the results of a nutrition-focused physical examination (NFPE) in paediatric patients9. MUAC is a robust indicator for determining malnutrition in paediatric patients, particularly those with cancer4. It is also the best predictor of malnutrition in the paediatric cancer patient population below the 5th percentile18. However, several studies have shown different results regarding MUAC. A 2023 study in Ethiopia, for example, found no significant association between MUAC and infections and length of stay in paediatric patients undergoing elective surgery14. A 2022 study in India by Gupta also showed no significant difference in survival rates in paediatric cancer patients when compared with anthropometric indices such as height/age and body mass index (BMI/age)18. Similarly, a study in Brazil found that MUAC contributed little to predicting cancer survival in paediatric patients15. This can be assumed because the accuracy of the MUAC can be affected by variations in growth and puberty in older paediatric, so its use needs to be combined with other indicators such as weight/height or other validated clinical assessments to improve diagnostic accuracy4.
In an effort to overcome the limitations of anthropometric malnutrition assessment methods, several studies have combined anthropometric measurements with other approaches such as nutrition-focused physical examination (NFPE), functional assessment through hand-grip strength (HGS), and biochemical parameters (e.g., CRP). NFPE and HGS have been shown to identify muscle mass loss and decreased physical function that are not always detected through conventional anthropometry, and have shown correlations with inflammatory markers2. NFPE, as a method for determining paediatrichood malnutrition, also has good consistency with validated tools or instruments9. On the other hand, HGS is also a method for assessing malnutrition status as an indicator of fat-free mass and muscle function8,3. HGS is sensitive in detecting decreased muscle function through decreased measurement results in paediatric patients at high risk of malnutrition8. HGS is significantly correlated with the assessment method for paediatrichood malnutrition through the biochemical results of CRP, which demonstrates a relationship between inflammation and decreased fat-free mass. Clinically, HGS is an objective indicator of muscle mass and inflammatory status, which is certainly very important as an early marker of functional malnutrition3. Biochemical test results such as CRP reflect an inflammatory response that can worsen malnutrition and clinical outcomes, so CRP can be used as an inflammatory marker that strengthens the impact of malnutrition on clinical outcomes4. This method in SLR is known to have a statistically significant correlation with length of stay (LOS) in paediatric cancer patients13. However, limitations in equipment availability, the need for specialized training, for example in the technically difficult implementation of NFPE9, and the influence of acute inflammatory conditions limit the role of HGS and biochemical parameters (CRP) as primary tools for malnutrition assessment. A study conducted in the United States in 2024 failed to demonstrate a significant association between HGS and clinical outcomes such as complications, length of stay (LOS), and mortality8. There fore, the method of determining malnutrition status in paediatric patients using these indicators is more appropriately used not as the primary predictor of outcomes but as a complementary component in a comprehensive assessment approach4.
The SLR demonstrates findings from studies of several tools or instruments for determining the malnutrition status of paediatric patients used in hospitals in various countries. These tools or instruments are the AAIMP tool, ANPEDCancer, and SGNA, which have been validated for assessing the malnutrition status of paediatric patients in hospitals. The SLR results indicate that the AAIMP tool has the ability to identify the prevalence of paediatrichood malnutrition well. The AAIMP tool has good agreement when compared with several methods, tools, or instruments for malnutrition assessment, with either moderate or quite strong agreement. According to the results of a study conducted by Ong in 2023 in Malaysia, the AAIMP tool has a fairly good agreement with the validated tool or instrument, SGNA in paediatric patients hospitalized in general care6. The AAIMP tool also has a moderate level of consistency with the NFPE in a prospective cohort study in the United States9. However, the AAIMP tool was not statistically significant for medical outcomes, and is therefore considered inconsistent in predicting clinical outcomes such as length of hospital stay or complications9. This may be because the indicators assessed in the AAIMP tool are limited to anthropometric data and dietary adequacy. Therefore, it is less comprehensive in identifying malnutrition status influenced by disease factors, inflammation, and changes in body composition that are not always reflected in these two indicators1,2
Another known tool or instrument is ANPEDCancer, which is used to detect malnutrition in paediatric patients, especially in the paediatric oncology population or paediatric cancer patients. A 2023 prospective study in paediatric cancer patients found that ANPEDCancer has good sensitivity in detecting malnutrition and its prevalence in that population. ANPEDCancer was also shown to have statistical significance in the assessment of biochemical markers of inflammation (CRP) and clinical outcomes such as length of stay (LOS). ANPEDCancer shows moderate diagnostic accuracy in paediatric oncology patients or paediatric patients with cancer13. However, this tool or instrument is specifically limited to its use in a special population, namely paediatric cancer. The assessment indicators are also specific to that population, so it cannot be compared with equivalent tools or instruments in more comprehensive and multidimensional assessments of paediatrichood malnutrition used for other medical conditions13.
Among multidimensional clinical assessment tools for paediatrichood malnutrition, the SGNA is the most widely used and most consistently reported in included studies. The SGNA has demonstrated effective predictive ability for complications, readmission risk, and survival outcomes, particularly in paediatric populations with chronic diseases such as paediatrichood cancer5,6,15,25. The strength of the SGNA lies in its holistic approach that integrates anthropometric indicators, dietary history, functional status, and physical and clinical examinations. The SGNA is a valid malnutrition assessment tool for identifying malnutrition status21. The SGNA has stronger agreement with objective measurements than screening tools, especially for diagnosing malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients22. The effectiveness is more extensive compared to anthropometric assessment, especially in youn ger paediatric patients aged 1 to 12 months analysed from weight loss and symptoms of gastrointestinal problems25. SGNA is effective in predicting complications and the risk of readmission as proven by a study in Canada in 2024. The malnutrition status doubeling complications and the risk of readmission. Statistical evidence shows that SGNA can predict paediatric patients identified as malnourished who are hospitalized experience complications and readmissions almost twice as much as those not identified as malnourished11. Studies related to the effectiveness of SGNA in predicting survival outcomes in paediatric cancer patients are proven by research in Brazil in 2023 by Afonso. A study in Brazil found that malnourished paediatric patients, assessed by SGNA, such as whose diagnosed with cancer had high Relative Risk (RR) of death compared to those without malnutrition15. The effectiveness of this prediction was statistically proven through the assessment of low body weight and mortality16. However, a 2018 study by Pimenta of 61 hospitalized paediatric patients aged 0–12 years showed poor agreement between the SGNA and the WHO growth chart. The subjective nature of the SGNA assessment should then be combined with the WHO growth chart to improve the accuracy of malnutrition status assessment24.
Among the multidimensional malnutrition assessment tools identified in this review, the SGNA emerged as the most extensively investigated and consistently supported by the available evidence. The findings from the included studies indicate that SGNA has been evaluated not only for its diagnostic validity but also for its association with clinically relevant outcomes and its feasibility for routine clinical implementation. For diagnostic validity, SGNA demonstrated moderate to strong agreement with objective malnutrition assessment methods, including anthropometric indicators and the AND/ASPEN Indicators of Malnutrition in Paediatrics (AAIMP) tool, supporting its usefulness for identifying malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients6,21,22. Its multidimensional assessment, incorporating dietary history, anthropometric measurements, physical examination, and functional status, enables a more comprehensive evaluation than anthropometric measurements alone. However, not all studies reported complete agreement. Pimenta et al.24 found only fair agreement between SGNA and the WHO Growth Charts, suggesting that subjective clinical assessment should be complemented by objective anthropometric measurements to improve diagnostic accuracy. Regarding clinical outcomes, SGNA demonstrated consistent associations with clinically important outcomes across several studies. Paediatric identified as malnourished using SGNA had an increased risk of complications, prolonged hospital stay, hospital readmission, and poorer survival, particularly among patients with chronic diseases and paediatric cancer11,15,16. For example, Létourneau et al.11 reported that malnourished paediatric identified by SGNA experienced nearly twice the risk of complications and readmission compared with well-nourished patients. Similarly, studies conducted by Afonso et al.15,16 demonstrated that SGNA effectively predicted mortality and adverse clinical outcomes among paediatric oncology patients. These findings suggest that SGNA provides clinically meaningful information beyond nutritional classification by identifying patients at greater risk of unfavourable outcomes. For clinical feasibility, several practical considerations should be acknowledged. As SGNA integrates multiple domains of malnutrition assessment, including clinical judgment, dietary history, physical examination, and anthropometric evaluation, its implementation requires trained healthcare professionals and may be more time-consuming than simple anthropometric screening methods. In addition, the subjective components of SGNA may introduce variability between assessors if standardized training is not provided. Therefore, although SGNA appears to be one of the most comprehensive multidimensional assessment tools identified in this review, it should be considered as part of an integrated malnutrition assessment strategy rather than a standalone diagnostic method.
This SLR identified the prevalence of malnutrition in paediatric with chronic diseases, malignancies, gastrointestinal disorders, infections, and inflammatory conditions2,28 who used malnutrition assessment methods and tools. The review demonstrated that the use of malnutrition assessment methods and tools was significantly associated with various clinical outcome indicators, including increased length of stay, risk of complications, infection, inflammation, functional decline, increased risk of readmission, and even death29. The consistent relationship between malnutrition status and clinical outcomes underscores the importance of accurate and timely malnutrition assessment in paediatric patients in hospitals, and the relatively high time burden hinders routine implementation, particularly in health care facilities with limited resources and high workloads5. While these various methods and tools are useful, none optimally integrates all the important dimensions of the multidimensional concept of paediatrichood malnutrition. Conceptually, the literature confirms that paediatrichood malnutrition is a complex condition and cannot be reduced solely to anthropometric deficits. McCarthy et al.1 emphasize that determining a paediatric’s malnutrition status must consider the interaction between anthropometric indicators, the aetiology and chronicity of the disease, the mechanisms of malnutrition, imbalanced nutrient intake, and their impact on function and clinical outcomes.
Overall, the findings from this SLR consistently demonstrate that a multimodal approach combining anthropometric methods, validated tools or instruments, and functional and biochemical indicators, when possible, provides better diagnostic accuracy than a single approach5,29. This integrated approach allows for accurate and targeted identification of malnutrition, which in turn supports more effective nutrition interventions and potentially improves clinical outcomes in hospitalized paediatric patients. The SLR demonstrates a clear gap between the complexity of the concept of paediatrichood malnutrition and the applicability of available and used assessment methods and tools. International literature emphasizes that determining paediatrichood malnutrition status must be comprehensive and multidimensional1,28. These findings align with the principles of health instrument development, which emphasize the importance of balancing conceptual validity with clinical feasibility. An ideal instrument is not only capable of measuring the construct accurately, but also can be used consistently by health workers in real-world practice. Thus, the results of the SLR provide a strong scientific basis, not merely a methodological innovation, but rather a response to real clinical needs consistently identified in the literature. This SLR serves as the primary basis for determining indicators, item structure, and the direction of development future malnutrition assessment instruments.
Conclusion
Malnutrition in hospitalized paediatric patients remains a prevalent and clinically significant condition with substantial impact on patient outcomes. This review demonstrates that no single method is sufficient for comprehensive nutritional assessment. Anthropometric measures, although widely used, have important limitations in clinical settings. Multidimen sional approaches, particularly those integrating anthropometric, clinical, and functional indicators, provide more accurate and clinically relevant assessments. Validated tools such as the Subjective Global Nutritional Assessment (SGNA) show strong potential for improving diagnostic accuracy and predicting clinical outcomes. Future efforts should focus on developing standardized, reliable, and clinically feasible assessment strategies to support early detection and improve the management of malnutrition in paediatric hospital settings.
Reference
Explorar
Artículos
Volúmenes
Sobre la revista
Más leídos
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria