Artículo original
Vol. 46 Núm. 3 (2026)
24 min
Sonia Faustina RIVERA HIJAR1, Alexandra INCIO CHIRA1, Sofía L. BOHÓRQUEZ-MEDINA1, Andrea L. BOHÓRQUEZ-MEDINA2
1 Carrera de Arte Culinario, Facultad de Administración Hotelera, Turismo y Gastronomía, Universidad San Ignacio de Loyola, Lima, Peru.
2 Carrera de Innovación y Gestión en Gastronomía, Facultad de Administración Hotelera, Turismo y Gastronomía, Universidad San Ignacio de Loyola, Lima, Peru.
Cómo citar
Métricas
220
Visualizaciones
29
Descargas
Compartir
Compartir
Resumen (EN)
Introduction: In recent years, overweight and obesity have become increasingly prevalent among adults, partly due to the frequent consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages. This context has increased the need for healthier beverage alternatives formulated with natural functional ingredients such as Peruvian cocoa (Theobroma cacao L.).
Objective: This study aimed to develop sugar-free functional beverages formulated with different natural Peruvian cocoa powder, sweetened with monk fruit, and evaluate their sensory acceptance.
Methods: Three beverage formulations were developed containing 5% 7% and 10% concentration of natural Peruvian cocoa powder, while maintaining constant amounts of unsweetened almond milk, monk fruit, psyllium, and salt. Sensory evaluation was conducted with 60 untrained adults. A 9-point hedonic scale was used to assess color, aroma, flavor, texture and overall acceptability.
Results: Cocoa concentration significantly influenced color and flavor attributes. The formulation containing 10% cocoa obtained the highest mean score for color (7.38 ± 1.22), whereas the 5% cocoa content achieved the highest scores for flavor (7.03 ± 1.33) and overall acceptance (7.10 ± 1.18). Significant differences were found among all formulations, for color, however flavor differed only between the 5% and 7% formulations. No significant differences were found for aroma, texture or overall acceptability.
Conclusions: The formulation containing 5% natural Peruvian cocoa showed the best balance between sensory characteristics and consumer acceptance. These findings support the use of natural cocoa, almond milk, and monk fruit as a suitable strategy for developing sugar-free functional beverages with potential as healthier alternatives for young adults.
Palabras clave (EN):
Introduction
The prevalence of obesity has continuously increased over the past decades, and is now considered a major public health concern worldwide. Since 1975, nearly four out of every ten adults now classified as overweight and one in eight living with obesity1. Excess body weight is associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, several types of cancer, and premature mortality2. Among the dietary factors contributing to this epidemic, sugar-sweetened beverages have received considerable attention because they increase added sugar intake. This type of sugar is easily absorbed and increase insulin secretion, while offering little to no satiety, thereby promoting excessive energy intake and metabolic dysfunction3,4.
Young adults are particularly susceptible to unhealthy dietary patterns. Busy academic schedules, energy-dense foods, and the widespread availability of sugar-sweetened beverages often displace healthier dietary choices. These practices have been linked with higher body mass index, inadequate nutrient intake, and poor consumption of fruits, vegetables, and dietary fiber5.Thus, improving the nutritional quality of foods and beverages usually consumed by this population has therefore become a major public health goal.
Peruvian cocoa (Theobroma cacao L.) in this sense is a promising ingredient for developing healthier beverages. Peru is not only recognized for its cultural and gastronomic relevance, but also as one of the world centres of cocoa diversity, with beans of extraordinary genetic variability and high sensory quality6,7. Cocoa powder is naturally rich in flavanols, methylxanthines, and other phenolic compounds associated with antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, cardiometabolic, and neuroprotective properties8. However, cocoa is predominantly consumed as confectionery products with high amounts of sugar and fat, thus restricting its potential as a functional food ingredient9.
Recent research has broadened the knowledge on the bioactive compounds of cocoa and their physiological effects. However, few studies have addressed the development of functional beverages formulated with Peruvian cocoa powder as the main ingredient and the evaluation of consumer acceptance simultaneously. Previous beverage formulations have focused primarily on cocoa by-products such as cocoa husk, rather than cocoa powder itself10,11. This is an important research gap, as consumer acceptance is crucial for the successful integration of functional products into daily dietary habits.
The development of cocoa-based beverages also requires a balance between nutritional quality and sensory acceptability. The higher the cocoa concentration, the better the content of bioactive compounds. However, it may increase the bitterness and astringency, which reduces consumer preference. Thus, the search for formulations that can preserve the functional properties of cocoa and at the same time preserve the favorable sensory characteristics remains an important challenge in product development. The objective of this study was to prepare three functional beverages with varying concentrations of Peruvian cocoa powder and to assess their sensory acceptance by young adults using a nine- point hedonic scale. The results could help in the development of healthier beverage alternatives and in the promotion of Peruvian cocoa as a functional ingredient with potential applications in the food industry.
Health Benefits of Cocoa
Cardiometabolic Health
During the last two decades, many studies have been carried out on the cardiometabolic effects of cocoa, mainly due to its high content of flavanols and other phenolic compounds. Experimental and clinical evidence suggests that regular consumption of cocoa has the potential to improve endothelial function, glycemic control, lipid metabolism and blood pressure, and to reduce oxidative stress and systemic inflammation8. The biological effects are mainly linked to flavanols and especially epicatechin which increases nitric oxide bioavailability and helps to maintain vascular homeostasis.
Other data suggest that cocoa polyphenols may improve insulin sensitivity and relieve different metabolic changes associated with obesity and type 2 diabetes mellitus, further supporting their potential in the prevention of chronic non-communicable diseases12. Many of these findings need to be confirmed by long-term clinical studies, but they consistently place cocoa among the most promising functional ingredients for cardiometabolic health.
The intensity of these physiological effects is mainly dependent on the concentration of bioactive compounds present in the final product. Therefore, beverages prepared with higher cocoa concentrations may deliver greater amounts of flavanols and phenolic compounds. At the same time, high cocoa content can lead to increased bitterness and astringency, which poses a significant technological challenge to reconcile functional value with consumer acceptance.
Cognitive Function
Cocoa bioactive compounds have also attracted considerable attention because of their potential effects on cognitive function. Flavanols and methylxanthines are involved in mechanisms related with cerebral blood flow, neuronal signaling, mitochondrial function, and protection against oxidative damage, all of which are involved in maintaining normal brain function13.
These properties are especially relevant for young adults and university students, whose academic performance depends on sustained attention, learning capacity, and cognitive efficiency. Although cognitive outcomes were not evaluated in the present study, the development of cocoa beverages that can maintain these bioactive compounds might help in future nutritional strategies for health and cognitive performance.
From a formulation point of view, the conservation of these compounds depends on the choice of suitable processing conditions and a sufficient amount of cocoa. Excessive processing reduces the availability of flavanols, while increasing the content of natural cocoa may improve the functional profile of the beverage and at the same time changes its sensory characteristics.
Gut Microbiota and Body Composition
There is growing evidence that cocoa polyphenols modify the intestinal microbiota by promoting the growth of beneficial bacteria and controlling inflammatory pathways associated with metabolic health14. Such interactions seem to favor a better intestinal homeostasis and could partly explain the systemic benefits observed after a regular cocoa consumption.
Also, the intake of cocoa, especially when it is minimally processed to preserve its flavanol content, has been associated with lower adiposity parameters. Commercial chocolate products are frequently high in added sugar and fat, which decreases their nutritional value, whereas natural cocoa powder contains much higher levels of these compounds15. This difference highlights the importance of selecting the appropriate cocoa ingredient for the development of functional foods that promote healthier eating patterns.
The alternatives to sugar-sweetened products should increase the biological value of drinks by maximizing the natural cocoa concentration. However, higher concentrations may also affect sensory properties such as bitterness, astringency, color and overall palatability. Thus, the development of a formulation that can reach important levels of bioactive compounds, and at the same time is well accepted by the consumer, is a key step for the production of functional cocoa drinks. In summary, these findings suggest that the functional value of natural cocoa is not limited to its antioxidant properties but involves multiple biological mechanisms related to cardiometabolic health, cognitive function and modulation of the gut microbiota. Increased cocoa concentration, on the other hand, could influence sensory properties of the final product and, therefore, it is important to find a balance between functional benefits and consumer acceptance. Figure 1 summarizes the main bioactive compounds present in cocoa, their proposed mechanisms of action, potential health benefits and the main formulation challenges related to their use in functional beverages.
Development of Cocoa-Based Functional Beverages
The functional beverage segment has undergone significant changes in recent years as consumers seek products that are nutritious and possess the right sensory attributes. Functional formulated beverages are not your everyday beverage that you drink to hydrate or energize you. They are believed to contain bioactive components that promote health or lower the risk of chronic diseases16. One of the most promising ingredients in this framework has been cocoa due to its naturally high content of flavanols and other phenolic compounds and demonstrated consumer acceptance. The functional properties of the obtained beverages are formed mainly according to the technological methods of production of cocoa beverages and the types of cocoa raw materials. The concentration of flavanols, antioxidant capacity, color, aroma and flavor of the final product are influenced by the processing conditions, such as fermentation, roasting and alkalization17,18. Alkali. Cut the bitterness and enhance the color. It also leads to a reduction of phenolic compounds responsible for many biological properties of cocoa. And to get the most functionality out of the drink, it is often best to select natural cocoa powder.
In the development of a cocoa beverage, one problem is the balance of nutritional quality with sensory acceptance. The percentage of cocoa increases leads to higher levels of bioactive compounds, but also to higher bitterness, astringency, viscosity and color intensity, characteristics that greatly influence the consumer preference4,19. Less cocoa means better taste but you also get fewer of the health-boosting compounds with each serving. One of the main challenges in functional beverage development is to find the concentration that best balances these properties. The choice of the complementary ingredients also affects the acceptance by consumers. The smooth sensory matrix of almond milk and other plant-based beverages can compensate for the innate bitterness of cocoa and meet the expanding market demand for dairy-free products20. Moreover, natural sweeteners such as monk fruit can provide sweetness without free sugars, thereby preserving the nutritional value of the beverage and ensuring good sensory acceptance21. Use of hydrocolloids such as psyllium can also enhance mouthfeel and physical stability with minimal flavor alteration23.
Moreover, the cocoa husk and other by-products of cocoa are used to make beverages24. These studies support the feasibility of beverages from cocoa, however, with less studies about formulas elaborated with natural Peruvian cocoa powder as a main functional ingredient and evaluated by the consumer sensory acceptance. This represents an interesting opportunity for product development, especially if the intention is to maintain the bioactive profile of cocoa and to produce a drink that would be acceptable for regular consumption.
Considering these aspects, the evaluation of beverages prepared with different concentrations of natural Peruvian cocoa opens the possibility to define the equilibrium between the functional value and the sensory quality. This approach is useful to identify formulations able to deliver high amounts of cocoa bioactives and maintain the consumer acceptance necessary for future commercialization.
Materials and Methods
Three formulations of a cocoa-based beverage were made, varying the cacao concentration and keeping constant the rest of ingredients (Table 1). The beverages were mixed to a temperature of 50-60ºC and served cold (approximately 10ºC) to conserve better its bioactive properties17.
Preparation of the formulations
The three cacao-based beverage formulations (FP1, FP2, and FP3) were prepared following the stepwise protocol illustrated in Figure 2. Briefly, 250 mL of unsweetened almond milk was heated to 55 ± 3 °C. The corresponding amount of cacao powder (12.5 g for FP1, 17.5 g for FP2, or 25.0 g for FP3) was added and homogenized using a hand blender (RECORD, maximum speed) for 2 min. Subsequently, 2 g of monk fruit extract and 1 g of psyllium husk were incorporated and blended for an additional 2 min. After removing from the heat source, 1 g of NaCl was added and dissolved. Figure 2 summarizes the standardized preparation procedure, including the sequence of ingredient addition, mixing conditions, and the final appearance of the three beverage formulations.
Sensory evaluation
There was a sensory evaluated conducted for the three samples of the beverage with different cacao percentages (5%,7% and 10%) with a panel of 60 untrained young adults from both genders, with ages between 18 and 30 years old, selected by a non-probability sampling by convenience.
To quantify the preference of each sample we used a 9-point hedonic scale, in which ranges from maximum aversion1 until maximum enjoyment9, passing a central point of indifference5. This scale allowed 5 sensory attributes to be tested: color, scent, taste, texture and global acceptance25,26. To control the order of the presentation and minimize biases, each panelist received three samples identified with three-digit numeric codes assigned randomly. Between samples there was water consumption to neutralize the palate and avoid sensory interferences.
Statistical Methodology
The analysis of the data from the sensory evaluation was used in the software Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 26 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). To determine the right statistical tests, the Levene test was applied to verify the assumption of homogeneity of variances. The results showed that Color (p=0.066), Scent (p=0.196) and Texture (p=0.325) fulfilled the assumption of homogeneity. However, Taste (p=0.006) and Global Acceptance (p=0.047) had heterogeneous variances, so there was an application of no-parametric tests (Mann-Whitney U) for the comparisons post hoc. From those results, there was an application of Kruskal-Wallis for the five attributes to pare the three formulations, with a level of confidence of α=0.05. For the attributes with different significances (Color and Taste), there were comparison by pares through Mann Whitney U.
Results
It’s important to point out that Kruskal Wallis was applied to the five evaluated attributes. For the color and taste attributes that presented statistical differences were done post hoc Mann Whitney U to identify the specific comparisons between the formulation pairs.
The P3 formulation (10% cacao) had the highest mean in color (7.38±1.22), while the P1 formulation (5% cacao) emphasized the taste (7.0±1.33) and the global acceptance (7.10±1.18). The P2 formulation (7% cacao) had the lowest punctuation in taste (6.25) and global acceptance (6.72).
Since Kruskal-Wallis revealed significant differences in the attributes of Color and Taste, several comparisons were made by pairs by the Mann-Whitney U test to identify which specific formulations differ between them.
Figure 4 shows a complete picture of the sensory profiles of the three beverage formulations. FP3 (10% cocoa) received the highest average score for color, while the highest scores for flavor and overall acceptability were given to FP1 (5% cocoa). Differences in the aroma and texture of the different formulations were minor, suggesting similar sensory experiences for these attributes. The radar chart indicates that all three beverages are positively perceived in terms of sensory characteristics, but differ significantly in color and flavor.
For the Color attribute (Table 3), the P3 formulation (10% cacao) had the largest mean range (72.19) followed by P2 (66.62) and P1 (48.81). The differences were statistically significant in all the comparisons by pairs (p<0.05), being the biggest difference between P1 and P3 (p=0.000).
For the flavor attribute (Table 3), a significant difference was found between P1 (5% cacao) and P2 (7% cacao), with a p = 0,019. The P1 formulation had a greater medium range (67,78) in respect to P2 (53,22). No significant differences were found between P2 vs P3 (p = 0,051) nor between P1 vs P3 (p = 0,996). However, the comparation between P2 vs P3 approached the significance threshold (p = 0.051), suggesting a trend.
The sensorial evaluation of the three formulations (FP1, FP2 and FP3) were cantered on the five key attributes: color, scent, taste and global acceptance.
Discussions
The present study evaluated the sensory acceptance of three cocoa-based beverages formulated with different concentrations of Peruvian cocoa powder while maintaining the same proportions of almond milk, monk fruit, psyllium, and salt. Although all three formulations received favorable sensory scores, the beverage containing 5% cocoa achieved the highest ratings for flavor and overall acceptance, whereas the formulation containing 10% cocoa received the highest score for color. These findings suggest that moderate cocoa concentrations provide a better balance between visual appeal and palatability, particularly among young adult consumers.
This preference for lower cocoa drinks is consistent with other studies on dark chocolate products using similar sensory methodologies. Products with moderate cocoa levels are generally better accepted by consumers than products with high cocoa concentrations. This is mainly because of the higher bitterness and astringency caused by the higher presence of phenolic compounds27. In the current research, a beverage (rather than solid chocolate) was tested; however, the two products showed similar sensory profiles, suggesting that flavor is the main driver of consumer preference, in spite of the health benefits associated with higher levels of cocoa.
Similar trends have also been seen in the development of functional cocoa beverages. It appears that the combination of cocoa with other ingredients that can reduce the bitterness of cocoa, but preserve its bioactive properties, improves the consumers’ acceptance. The monk fruit sweetened the drink without adding calories, and the almond milk probably improved the mouthfeel. These components combined may have attenuated the sensory effects of cocoa polyphenols, while maintaining the functional properties expected of a cocoa-based beverage17,28. This formulation strategy may account for the fact that all beverages were rated positively in sensory evaluation even without added sugar.
Previous studies have shown that monk fruit can produce highly acceptable products in the absence of sucrose or artificial sweeteners, which supported the choice of monk fruit as the sweetening agent. Consumer acceptance of monk fruit sweetened dairy products was comparable to traditionally sweetened products, indicating the natural sweetener was able to mask bitterness and provide a desirable sensory profile21. The present study showed similar behavior, where all formulations obtained acceptable acceptance scores with the increasing concentrations of cocoa. This finding highlights the potential of monk fruit as a viable sweetener for functional beverage development22.
The absence of significant alterations in aroma, texture and overall acceptance suggests that increasing the cocoa content in the range tested did not have a significant impact on these sensory attributes. Similar results have been found in previous studies on dairy chocolate drinks, showing that consumers are generally accepting of natural cocoa powder in different food matrices when properly formulated29. However, the current research findings suggest that plant-based beverages may provide a similar sensory experience thus expanding the options available for dairy abstainers, despite the significant compositional differences between buffalo milk and almond milk.
The only characteristic that increased with increasing cocoa concentration was the color. The participants preferred the darker color of the 10% cocoa formulation, confirming the importance of visual characteristics in the first sensory evaluations. The perception of richness and the product quality have been improved with darker cocoa beverages, according to studies on cocoa beverages processed by different methods19. Still, the better look did not translate to more acceptance of flavor. This inconsistency suggests that aesthetic appeal alone is not enough to predict consumer preference in higher levels of bitterness.
The chemical composition of cocoa is linked to the complex relationship between cocoa concentration and flavor preference. Higher concentrations increase levels of flavanol and other phenolic compounds associated with antioxidant activity, but also increase bitterness and astringency, two sensory attributes often negatively correlated with hedonic scores7,17. Results indicate that sensory deficiencies can be remedied by the addition of almond milk and monk fruit, while maintaining the functional benefits of natural cocoa and consumer liking.
The chemistry of cocoa accounts for the complex relationship of cocoa concentration with flavor acceptability. Higher levels increase flavanol and other phenolic compounds related to antioxidant activity but also increase bitterness and astringency, sensory attributes usually associated with lower hedonic scores7,17. The results of this study showed that the addition of almond milk and monk fruit could overcome sensory limitations and maintain the functional properties of natural cocoa without compromising consumer acceptability.
Beverages with cocoa content have further nutritional advantages, because they contain a large number of bioactive compounds with antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and cardiometabolic properties13. Possible reduction of muscle soreness after exercise with cocoa consumption may be related to its flavanol content, according to experimental research30. The physiological effects were not evaluated in the present study. However, the feasibility of the proposed beverage as a functional food combining consumer approval and nutritional benefits is confirmed. Young adults often have poor dietary practices and there is a need to develop healthier beverage options for this age group. Since them do not consume adequate amounts of fruits, vegetables and dietary fiber and consume too much energy-dense foods. This puts them at risk of being overweight or obese5. A cocoa-based beverage sweetened with monk fruit is a good alternative to sugar- sweetened drinks, with enjoyable sensory attributes and less added sugar.
Evidence suggests that the best functional beverages based on cocoa should find an adequate compromise between nutrition and sensory quality.
The present findings support previous observations showing that moderate cocoa concentrations maximize consumer preference while preserving the functional properties associated with cocoa polyphenols19,27. At the same time, the incorporation of almond milk and monk fruit appears to be an effective formulation strategy for reducing bitterness without relying on refined sugars or cocoa alkalization, thereby preserving the natural bioactive profile of cocoa.
The results of this study should be considered in light of its limitations. The functional characteristics of the beverages were not explicitly evaluated in the final formulations, but conclusions were drawn from the established bioactive profile of natural cocoa. The investigation was primarily concerned with sensory acceptance. The sensory evaluation was performed only with young adults, which may limit the generalization of the results to other consumer groups. The beverages were analyzed immediately after preparation, thus the physicochemical stability and shelf-life characteristics were not evaluated. Sensory, physicochemical and nutritional analyses should be included in future studies to fully evaluate cocoa-based functional beverages.
Conclusions
The sensory acceptance of cocoa-based functional beverages was influenced by the concentration of natural Peruvian cocoa powder. Of the three formulations the 5% cocoa beverage was liked best in terms of flavor and overall acceptance while the 10% formulation was liked best in terms of color. The results suggest that a moderate level of cocoa offers a better compromise between sensory quality and consumer choice.
The use of natural cocoa powder, almond milk, and monk fruit was effective as a strategy of formulation to develop a sugar-free functional beverage with good consumer acceptance. Higher cocoa concentration can improve the levels of bioactive compounds, but also increase sensory features, such as bitterness and astringency, highlighting the importance of balancing nutritional value with sensory appeal in product development.
The study supports the application of Peruvian cocoa as a functional ingredient in the formulation of healthier beverages and demonstrates that sensory acceptance should be assessed together with the functional properties of cocoa when establishing the optimal concentration for product development.
Future Perspectives
Follow-up studies should evaluate intermediate cocoa concentrations to better delineate the threshold at which sensory acceptance and functional value are best balanced. Additional physicochemical analyses, such as total polyphenol content, flavanol concentration, antioxidant capacity, color stability, viscosity and shelf-life evaluation, would provide a more complete characterization of the beverage.
Further research with larger and more heterogeneous consumer groups and trained sensory panels would increase the external validity of these results and provide a more complete understanding of sensory characteristics such as bitterness, astringency, sweetness, and mouthfeel. Evaluating consumer perception in different age groups and dietary habits may allow the discovery of market opportunities for cocoa-based functional beverages.
Finally, clinical and nutritional intervention studies are needed to verify if the consumption of beverages prepared with natural Peruvian cocoa maintains the expected physiological benefits due to its regular intake. The combination of sensory, physicochemical and nutritional data will allow the development of functional beverages with greater potential for commercial success and improvement of public health.
References
Explorar
Artículos
Volúmenes
Sobre la revista
Más leídos
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria