Artículo original
Vol. 46 Núm. 3 (2026)
34 min
Nurul RAHMADANI1, Abdul SALAM2, Nurhaedar JAFAR2, Nurzakiah HASAN2, Anna KHUZAIMAH2
1 Master of Nutrition Science Department, Faculty of Public Health, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia.
2 Department of Nutritional Science, Faculty of Public Health, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia.
Cómo citar
Métricas
223
Visualizaciones
22
Descargas
Compartir
Compartir
Resumen (EN)
Background: Fluid loss and inadequate energy intake are common among adolescent soccer players and may negatively affect physical performance. Modified isotonic beverages have been proposed as a nutritional strategy to support hydration and energy balance; however, evidence regarding their effects on nutritional intake and physical performance remains limited.
Objective: To evaluate the effects of a modified coconut water–based isotonic beverage compared with young coconut water on energy intake, aerobic capacity (VO2max), and abdominal muscle endurance among adolescent soccer players.
Methods: A randomized controlled trial with a two-group pretest–posttest design was conducted among 43 adolescent soccer players from a specialized sports high school in Indonesia. Participants were assigned to an intervention group (n = 23), which received a modified isotonic beverage formulated from mature coconut water, sweet orange juice, and palm sugar, or a control group (n = 20), which received young coconut water as an active comparator rather than a placebo. Assessments were performed at baseline, day 8, and day 15. Energy intake was assessed using 24-hour dietary recalls, aerobic capacity (VO2max) was measured using the Balke test, and abdominal muscle endurance was evaluated using the sit-up test. Within-group changes from baseline were analyzed using paired t-tests, while between-group differences in outcome changes were compared using independent t-tests.
Results: Baseline characteristics were comparable between groups (p > 0.05). Both groups demonstrated significant increases in energy intake during the intervention period; however, the mean increase was significantly greater in the intervention group than in the control group (660.9 ± 493.4 vs. 366.9 ± 396.5 kcal; p = 0.039). Simi larly, VO2max improved significantly in both groups, with a significantly greater mean increase observed in the intervention group compared with the control group (2.71 ± 1.54 vs. 1.90 ± 0.89 mL/kg/min; p = 0.048). Abdominal muscle endurance also increased significantly from baseline in both groups; however, the magnitude of improvement did not differ significantly between groups (p = 0.419).
Conclusion: Consumption of a modified coconut water–based isotonic beverage was associated with greater improvements in energy intake and aerobic capacity compared with young coconut water among adolescent soccer players. Although abdominal muscle endurance improved within both groups, no significant difference in the magnitude of change was observed between groups. These findings suggest that a modified natural isotonic beverage may serve as a practical nutritional strategy to support hydration, energy availability, and aerobic performance in adolescent soccer players.
Palabras clave (EN):
Introduction
Maintaining adequate fluid balance and energy availability is foundational to physiological homeostasis, exercise tolerance, and competitive performance1–4. Soccer is characterized by high-intensity intermittent demands that significantly elevate fluid and caloric requirements5–7. During training and competitions, athletes commonly incur substantial losses through perspiration and respiration, heightening susceptibility to dehydration and performance deterio ration8–11.
Cumulative research has documented elevated dehydration prevalence among soccer athletes, particularly adolescents, who often fail to consume adequate fluids before, during, and after physical exertion5. Fluid deficits exceeding 2% of body mass have been linked to impaired aerobic output, diminished cognitive responsiveness, and reduced exercise capacity, while more severe dehydration may predispose athletes to heat-related health conditions5,9.
Beyond fluid depletion, suboptimal energy consumption represents a prevalent nutritional challenge among young competitive athletes. The adolescent period is marked by concurrent rapid somatic development and intensive training loads, creating substantially elevated nutritional demands7,12,13. When dietary energy fails to offset expenditure from both exercise and physiological growth, a state of low energy availability (LEA) arises13,14. Prolonged LEA is associated with Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S), adversely affecting metabolism, recovery capacity, health status, and performance13–15. Multiple investigations have documented inadequate caloric consumption among adolescent soccer athletes, underscoring the need for strategies capable of simultaneously addressing hydration and energy requirements8,13,16–18.
Aerobic fitness and muscular endurance represent foundational performance attributes in soccer. Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) reflects the integrated capacity of the cardiovascular and respiratory systems to deliver and utilize oxygen during sustained exertion and is broadly recognized as a principal marker of aerobic fitness5,16,19. Concurrently, abdominal muscular endurance underpins core stability, biomechanical efficiency, postural control, and injury resilience throughout repeated high-intensity efforts18,20,21. Interventions that simultaneously target hydration status and energy availability may therefore exert beneficial effects on these performance-critical parameters2,5,11,17.
Isotonic beverages are frequently advocated during exercise owing to their capacity to replenish fluid losses, supply rapidly absorbed carbohydrates, and maintain electrolyte equilibrium3,22–24. Natural food-derived isotonic alternatives have attracted growing scientific attention as substitutes for commercially manufactured sports drinks13,19,25. Among these, coconut water has garnered considerable interest as a naturally occurring isotonic fluid, given its favorable electrolyte composition, carbohydrate content, and rehydration properties. Earlier studies demonstrated that coconut water effectively supports fluid restoration and sustains hydration following physical exertion8.
Coconut water has been widely studied as a potential natural sports beverage because of its composition of electrolytes, carbohydrates, and bioactive compounds that may support hydration, recovery, and overall fluid balance19,26,27. Prior research suggests that coconut water can effectively replenish fluid losses and sustain hydration status after exercise bouts6.
Mature coconut water is relatively rich in carbohydrates, potassium, sodium, and various bioactive constituents that may collectively support hydration, facilitate exercise recovery, and help maintain fluid homeostasis26. Compared with young coconut water, the mature variety typically exhibits higher concentrations of carbohydrates and dissolved solids, potentially augmenting its utility as a natural sports beverage. When combined with carbohydrate sources such as sweet orange juice and palm sugar, mature coconut water may address both hydration and energy requirements during training and recovery. Such formulations have been shown to align with Indonesian National Standards (SNI 01-4452-1998) for isotonic beverages, affirming their potential as a naturally derived sports drink23,24.
Notwithstanding expanding interest in naturally derived isotonic beverages, empirical evidence concerning their effects on physical performance in adolescent athletes remains limited. Most prior research has focused on rehydration endpoints, while the potential influence on caloric intake and performance markers has been comparatively underexplored7,19,28,29. Data specific to natural isotonic beverages among Indonesian adolescent athletes are particularly scarce, despite the country’s substantial coconut-based agricultural resources and the growing prevalence of competitive youth sport. To our knowledge, no previous randomized controlled trial has evaluated a modified isotonic formulation composed of mature coconut water, sweet orange juice, and palm sugar with respect to both nutritional and performance outcomes in adolescent soccer players23. Accordingly, this study was designed to evaluate the effects of this modified beverage on energy consumption, aerobic fitness (VO2max), and abdominal muscular endurance in adolescent soccer athletes in Indonesia5,16,18,30.
Materials and Methods
Study design and setting
A randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a two-group pretest–posttest design was conducted between August and November 2025 among adolescent soccer athletes enrolled at SMA Negeri Khusus Keberbakatan Olahraga (SMANKO), South Sulawesi Province, Indonesia. The intervention was implemented both at the school and at the athletes’ regular training facilities.
The study consisted of baseline assessment (day 0), intermediate assessment (day 8), and final assessment (day 15). The primary outcomes were aerobic capacity (VO2max), abdominal muscle endurance, and energy intake.
Participants were randomly assigned to either the intervention group or the control group using a computer-generated randomization sequence generated through an online randomization platform. Allocation concealment was maintained using sealed opaque envelopes prepared by an independent researcher who was not involved in recruitment, intervention delivery, or outcome assessment.
A single-blind design was employed in which participants were unaware of their beverage allocation. To minimize perception bias, both beverages were served in identical non- transparent bottles with the same volume and under the same serving conditions. Because the modified natural isotonic drink was freshly prepared on each intervention day due to its limited shelf life, the researcher responsible for beverage preparation and administration was aware of the group allocation. Likewise, outcome assessors were not blinded to group assignment. Therefore, blinding was applied only to the participants.
Participants
The study population consisted of all registered soccer athletes at the Specialized Sports High School of South Sulawesi Province. A total of 112 athletes were screened for eligibility, and 50 athletes who met the inclusion criteria and regularly attended training sessions were recruited into the study.
Sample size was calculated using the formula for comparing the means of two independent populations. Assuming a two-sided significance level of 5% (α = 0.05), statistical power of 95% (β = 0.05), a standard deviation of 2.35 mL/kg/min, and an expected mean difference of 3.47 mL/kg/min in endurance performance, the minimum required sample size was 17 participants per group. Sample size was estimated based on the expected effect of the intervention on VO2max from previous studies (33). To compensate for potential attrition, an additional 20% was added.
Participants were randomly allocated into intervention (n = 25) and control (n = 25) groups. During the intervention period, seven participants were excluded because of tournament participation outside the study area or attendance below 80%, resulting in a final sample of 43 athletes (intervention group, n = 23; control group, n = 20). No adverse events or gastrointestinal complaints were reported during the intervention period.
Inclusion criteria
Participants were eligible if they:
Exclusion criteria
Participants were excluded if they:
Dropout criteria
Participants were withdrawn if they:
Intervention
The intervention group received a modified isotonic beverage formulated from mature coconut water, sweet orange juice, and palm sugar. The beverage composition consisted of 80% mature coconut water (200 mL), 13% sweet orange juice (32.5 mL), and 7% palm sugar (17.5 g), yielding a total volume of 250 mL per serving. Sodium benzoate was added as a preservative according to food safety standards.
The control group received 250 mL of natural young coconut water, which served as an active comparator rather than a placebo beverage because of its naturally occurring electrolyte content.
Both beverages were administered once daily for 14 consecutive days, approximately 30 minutes before the athletes’ afternoon training sessions. Consumption was directly supervised by the research team to ensure adherence.
In addition to beverage administration, participants in both groups received standardized nutrition education regarding balanced nutrition and the Indonesian “My Plate” guidelines on days 0, 8, and 15 to ensure equal exposure to nutrition-related information. This nutrition education was implemented as a co-intervention to standardize nutritional knowledge across both groups and reduce potential confounding related to dietary education.
Quality assurance procedures were implemented throughout the intervention period. The modified isotonic beverage was formulated in accordance with the Indonesian National Standard for isotonic beverages (SNI 01-4452-1998). All measurement instruments were calibrated before data collection to ensure accuracy and reliability. Beverage consumption was directly supervised by the research team to maximize adherence. Participants were also monitored daily through a dedicated messaging group to assess compliance and identify potential adverse events. Any reported symptoms were documented and referred for medical evaluation when necessary.
Outcome measurements
Energy intake assessment
Dietary intake was assessed using a 24-hour dietary recall conducted by trained interviewers. Although widely used in nutritional studies, this method may not fully represent participants’ habitual dietary intake. Food photographs and household measurement aids were used to improve portion size estimation. Dietary data were analyzed using NutriSurvey software to estimate daily energy intake.
Aerobic capacity (VO2max)
Aerobic capacity was assessed using the Balke field test. Participants completed a standardized 15-minute running protocol, and VO2max was estimated from the total distance covered during the test. Results were expressed in mL/kg/min.
Abdominal muscle endurance
Abdominal muscle endurance was assessed using a standardized 1-minute sit-up test. The total number of correctly performed sit-ups completed within one minute was recorded.
Anthropometric measurements
Body weight was measured using a calibrated digital scale, while height was measured using a microtoise. Anthropo metric measurements were collected at baseline according to standardized procedures.
All outcome assessments were performed at baseline (day 0), day 8, and day 15.
Statistical analysis
Data were analyzed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 26.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).
Continuous variables were presented as means and standard deviations, whereas categorical variables were expressed as frequencies and percentages.
The normality of data distribution was evaluated using the Shapiro–Wilk test. Homogeneity of variance was assessed before conducting comparative analyses.
Within-group changes between baseline and follow-up assessments were analyzed using paired t-tests. Differences between the intervention and control groups were evaluated using independent t-tests. All statistical tests were two-tailed, and statistical significance was established at p < 0.05.
Ethical considerations
The study protocol was approved by the Health Research Ethics Committee of the Department of Nutrition, Faculty of Public Health, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia (Approval No. 147/UN4.14.1/TP.01.02/2025).
Written informed consent was obtained from all participants prior to enrollment. For participants younger than 18 years, parental or guardian consent was additionally obtained. All procedures were conducted in accordance with the ethical principles outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki.
Results
Baseline Characteristics of Participants
Table 1 summarizes the baseline demographic and anthropometric characteristics of participants in the intervention and control groups. The mean age of participants was 15.57 ± 0.59 years in the intervention group and 15.90 ± 0.72 years in the control group. No statistically significant differences were observed between groups for age, body weight, height, waist circumference, or body mass index (all p > 0.05). These findings indicate that the two groups were comparable at baseline prior to the intervention. Mean body mass index values were within the normal range in both groups.
Compliance with Intervention
Table 2 presents participant adherence to beverage consumption during the 14-day intervention period. Adherence was high in both groups, with complete adherence (100%) achieved by 73.9% of participants in the intervention group and 75.0% in the control group. Lower adherence levels of 80% and 90% were observed in a small proportion of participants in both groups. No significant difference in adherence distribution was found between the intervention and control groups (p = 0.971), indicating comparable compliance with the intervention protocol.
Effect on Energy Intake
Table 3 presents the changes in daily energy intake during the intervention period. At baseline, mean energy intake did not differ significantly between the intervention and control groups (1523.0 ± 404.0 vs. 1348.0 ± 421.1 kcal/day; p = 0.173). Following the intervention, participants receiving the modified isotonic beverage exhibited significantly higher energy intake than those in the control group on both day 8 (1794.0 ± 297.2 vs. 1506.0 ± 385.3 kcal/day; p = 0.009) and day 15 (2183.0 ± 334.9 vs. 1715.0 ± 394.3 kcal/day; p < 0.001).
Within-group analyses demonstrated significant increases in energy intake from baseline to day 15 in both the intervention group (p < 0.001) and the control group (p = 0.001). However, the magnitude of improvement was significantly greater among participants receiving the modified isotonic beverage (Δ = 660.9 ± 493.4 kcal/day) compared with those receiving natural coconut water (Δ = 366.9 ± 396.5 kcal/day), as indicated by the between-group comparison of change scores (p = 0.039). The increase in energy intake was greater in the intervention group than in the control group (mean difference = 294.03 kcal/day, 95% CI: 15.45–572.62; p = 0.039; Hedges’ g = 0.64).
A sensitivity analysis excluding the energy contribution of the modified isotonic beverage showed that the intervention group maintained a significantly higher energy intake at day 15 (p = 0.001), indicating that the observed increase was not solely attributable to the caloric content of the beverage.
Figure 1 illustrates the distribution of energy intake adequacy categories throughout the study period. In the intervention group, the proportion of participants classified as having a deficit energy intake (<70% RDA) decreased markedly from 47.8% at baseline to 21.7% on day 8 and was completely eliminated by day 15. Concurrently, the proportion of participants achieving adequate energy intake (≥90% RDA) increased substantially from 30.4% at baseline to 60.9% on day 8 and 91.3% on day 15.
In the control group, improvements in energy intake were also observed, although to a lesser extent. The prevalence of deficit energy intake decreased from 60.0% at baseline to 40.0% on day 8 and 30.0% on day 15. Meanwhile, the proportion of participants in the adequate intake category increased from 15.0% at baseline to 20.0% on day 8 and 35.0% on day 15.
Overall, the intervention group demonstrated a more pronounced shift toward adequate energy intake categories compared with the control group, indicating greater improvement in dietary energy adequacy during the intervention period.
Effect on Aerobic capacity (VO2max)
Table 4 presents the changes in aerobic capacity, measured by VO2max, during the intervention period. At baseline, no significant difference in VO2max was observed between the intervention and control groups (40.28 ± 5.28 vs. 37.29 ± 5.23 mL·kg-¹·min-¹; p = 0.071). Following the intervention, participants in the intervention group demonstrated significantly higher VO2max values than those in the control group on day 8 (41.66 ± 5.18 vs. 38.24 ± 5.5 mL·kg-¹·min-¹; p = 0.043) and day 15 (42.99 ± 4.86 vs. 39.20 ± 5.21 mL·kg-¹·min-¹; p = 0.018).
Within-group analyses showed significant improvements in VO2max from baseline to day 15 in both the intervention and control groups (both p < 0.001). However, the magnitude of improvement was significantly greater in the intervention group (Δ = 2.71 ± 1.54 mL·kg-¹·min-¹) compared with the control group (Δ = 1.90 ± 0.89 mL·kg-¹·min-¹), as indicated by the between-group comparison of change scores (p = 0.048). The intervention group showed a greater improvement in VO2max than the control group (mean difference = 0.80 mL·kg-¹·min-¹, 95% CI: 0.01–1.60; p = 0.048; Hedges’ g = 0.62). After adjustment for baseline VO2max, the difference remained significant (p = 0.014).
Effect of the Modified Isotonic Beverage on Abdominal Muscle Endurance
Table 5 presents the changes in abdominal muscle endurance during the intervention period. Baseline abdominal muscle endurance did not differ significantly between the intervention and control groups (42.48 ± 7.30 vs. 38.25 ± 6.60 repetitions; p = 0.057). Following the intervention, participants receiving the modified isotonic beverage achieved significantly higher abdominal muscle endurance scores than the control group on both day 8 (45.30 ± 7.20 vs. 41.25 ± 5.50 repetitions; p = 0.048) and day 15 (47.52 ± 7.80 vs. 42.00 ± 6.70 repetitions; p = 0.019).
Within-group analyses demonstrated significant improvements in abdominal muscle endurance from baseline to day 15 in both the intervention group (p < 0.001) and the control group (p = 0.009). However, the magnitude of improvement was greater in the intervention group (Δ = 5.04 ± 4.60 repetitions) than in the control group (Δ = 3.75 ± 5.70 repetitions), although this between-group difference did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.419). The between-group difference in the change in abdominal muscular endurance was not statistically significant (mean difference = 1.29 repetitions, 95% CI: −1.90 to 4.49, p = 0.419), with a small effect size (Hedges’ g = 0.24).
Discussion
Baseline Characteristics and Intervention Adherence
Baseline characteristics confirmed that participants in both groups were comparable with respect to age, anthropometric profiles, and pre-intervention outcome measures. The absence of pre-intervention differences validates the effectiveness of the randomization process and enhances confidence in the study’s internal validity, as pre-existing disparities in these variables could otherwise confound performance-related outcomes.
The majority of enrolled participants were approximately 15–16 years old, placing them in mid-adolescence—a phase distinguished by rapid somatic growth alongside marked neuromuscular and cardiovascular development. Ensuring adequate nutritional intake and hydration during this developmental window is essential for optimizing both athletic output and physiological maturation7,13,29.
Beverage compliance was consistently high and did not differ significantly between groups, indicating that the observed outcomes were unlikely to be confounded by unequal beverage exposure. Strong adherence also suggests favorable palatability and tolerance of both beverages, which is practically important when designing nutritional interventions for adolescent athlete populations13.
Effect of the Modified Isotonic Beverage on Energy Intake
One of the principal findings of this study was the significant improvement in energy intake among adolescent soccer players receiving the modified isotonic beverage. Although energy intake increased in both groups during the intervention period, the magnitude of improvement was significantly greater among participants in the intervention group. In addition, a substantially higher proportion of athletes in the intervention group achieved adequate energy intake by the end of the study. These findings, supported by the confidence interval and a moderate effect size, suggest that the modified isotonic beverage may contribute not only to hydration support but also to meaningful improvements in daily energy intake among adolescent athletes. Analysis excluding the energy provided by the intervention beverages showed no significant between-group difference on day 8, but the difference remained significant on day 15, suggesting that the improvement in energy intake was not solely attributable to the beverage’s caloric content and may also reflect the combined effects of the intervention and standardized nutrition education13,15.
Adequate energy intake is a fundamental requirement for athletic performance, physiological development, and long-term health during adolescence. Adolescent athletes experience elevated nutritional demands because they must simultaneously support growth, maturation, and intensive physical training. Previous research has demonstrated that energy expenditure among adolescent soccer players can exceed 3,000–3,500 kcal/day, with some highly trained individuals exhibiting even greater requirements depending on training load and competitive schedules. Failure to meet these energy demands may result in low energy availability (LEA), a condition in which dietary energy intake is insufficient to support both exercise energy expenditure and normal physiological functioning.
Low energy availability has been associated with REDs, a condition that negatively affects metabolic processes, hormonal regulation, bone health, and performance. Research consistently documents inadequate caloric intake among adolescent soccer players, reinforcing the importance of dietary strategies that simultaneously address both hydration and energy needs.
The greater caloric gains observed in the intervention group are likely attributable to the carbohydrate-dense composition of the modified beverage, which incorporated mature coconut water, palm sugar, and sweet orange11,19,24. These constituents not only supply fluid and electrolytes but also deliver readily bioavailable carbohydrates that augment total daily caloric consumption. Prior studies indicate that carbohydrate-containing sports beverages can enhance energy availability and facilitate recovery during high-volume training phases.
These findings align with existing evidence that sports beverages formulated with carbohydrates and electrolytes can improve energy availability, hydration status, and recovery in athletes engaged in regular intensive training5,11,17. Naturally derived beverages with favorable carbohydrate profiles may offer comparable benefits to commercially produced formulations while drawing on locally accessible ingredients.
An additional factor contributing to the observed outcomes may be the acceptability and sensory qualities of the modified isotonic beverage. Palatability is an important determinant of beverage consumption behavior, particularly among adolescents, and favorable taste characteristics may have encouraged greater fluid and carbohydrate intake throughout the intervention period.
From a practical standpoint, these findings suggest that naturally formulated isotonic beverages derived from locally accessible ingredients represent a viable nutritional strategy for augmenting caloric intake in adolescent soccer players, particularly in resource-constrained settings where commercial sports products may be limited in availability or affordability22–24.
Effect of the Modified Isotonic Beverage on Aerobic Capacity (VO2max)
Aerobic capacity improved significantly in both groups following the intervention period. However, participants who received the modified isotonic beverage demonstrated a significantly greater increase in VO2max compared with those who consumed coconut water alone. Supported by the confidence interval, a moderate effect size, and the adjusted ANCOVA analysis, these findings suggest that the modified beverage may have provided additional nutritional support that enhanced physiological adaptation to regular soccer training.
VO2max is widely recognized as one of the most important indicators of aerobic fitness in soccer players because the sport requires repeated high-intensity actions superimposed on prolonged intermittent activity. Adequate aerobic capacity supports recovery between repeated sprints, delays fatigue, and contributes to sustained match performance. Previous studies have shown that adolescent soccer players have substantial energy and fluid requirements due to the combined demands of growth, maturation, and intensive training schedules. Therefore, nutritional interventions that improve hydration status and energy availability may positively influence aerobic performance outcomes.
Several physiological mechanisms may explain the greater improvement observed in the intervention group. Adequate hydration is essential for maintaining plasma volume, cardiovascular stability, thermoregulation, and oxygen delivery during exercise. Even relatively small fluid deficits may impair aerobic performance and increase physiological strain during training. Position statements from the American College of Sports Medicine indicate that body water losses exceeding approximately 2% of body mass can compromise exercise performance and increase cardiovascular stress. Similarly, studies in soccer players have reported that dehydration is highly prevalent and may negatively affect endurance capacity and sport-specific performance5,16,19.
The hydration benefits observed may be partly attributable to the electrolyte composition of coconut water, particularly its high potassium content. Coconut water has been reported to provide rehydration efficacy comparable to commercially available carbohydrate-electrolyte sports drinks and may improve fluid retention following exercise-induced dehydration. Recent evidence further suggests that coconut water can effectively support post-exercise rehydration while maintaining good palatability and gastrointestinal tolerance in physically active individuals.
In addition to hydration support, the modified isotonic beverage supplied readily available carbohydrates from palm sugar and sweet orange juice. Carbohydrate availability plays a critical role in maintaining blood glucose concentrations, supporting glycogen utilization, and delaying the onset of fatigue during prolonged or repeated exercise. Carbohydrate-electrolyte beverages have consistently been shown to enhance endurance performance and improve exercise capacity compared with water alone, particularly during moderate-to-high intensity exercise. Therefore, the combination of carbohydrates and electrolytes contained in the modified beverage may have contributed to improved training quality and recovery, ultimately facilitating greater improvements in aerobic fitness.
Another possible explanation is the significant increase in energy intake observed among athletes in the intervention group. Adequate energy intake is necessary to support training adaptations and prevent low energy availability (LEA), which has been associated with impaired physiological function, reduced training responsiveness, and decreased athletic performance. Contemporary models of Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S) emphasize that insufficient energy availability can adversely affect multiple body systems involved in exercise performance. Thus, the additional energy provided by the modified isotonic beverage may have supported a more favorable metabolic environment for aerobic adaptation during the intervention period.
Although the between-group difference reached statistical significance, the magnitude of improvement remained moderate. This finding suggests that the modified isotonic beverage should be viewed as a complementary nutritional strategy rather than an independent determinant of aerobic fitness. Aerobic performance is multifactorial and influenced by training load, exercise intensity, recovery practices, sleep quality, maturation status, and overall dietary intake. Consequently, the observed improvement in VO2max likely reflects the combined influence of the nutritional intervention and ongoing soccer training rather than the beverage alone7,16.
Effect of the Modified Isotonic Beverage on Abdominal Muscle Endurance
Abdominal muscle endurance improved significantly within both groups throughout the intervention period. However, the magnitude of improvement did not differ significantly between groups, indicating that the modified isotonic beverage did not provide a measurable advantage over coconut water alone in enhancing abdominal muscle endurance over the 14-day intervention period. This interpretation was further supported by the confidence interval and a small effect size, indicating limited practical significance of the intervention on abdominal muscle endurance.
The improvements observed in both groups were most likely attributable to regular soccer training and physical conditioning activities performed throughout the study. Abdominal and core muscle endurance are highly trainable components of physical fitness that contribute to postural control, force transmission between the upper and lower extremities, movement efficiency, and injury prevention during soccer-specific activities. Because participants continued their routine training programs during the intervention period, improvements in muscular endurance would be expected regardless of beverage allocation. Furthermore, core endurance adaptations are generally driven by neuromuscular training stimuli rather than short-term nutritional interventions.
The lack of a significant between-group difference may also reflect the physiological determinants of muscular endurance. Although hydration and energy availability contribute to exercise performance, abdominal muscular endurance is influenced primarily by muscle conditioning status, neuromuscular coordination, motor unit recruitment, and local muscular adaptations. Consequently, nutritional interventions alone may exert a relatively limited effect on this performance component unless combined with specific resistance or core-strengthening programs.
Nevertheless, adequate hydration and carbohydrate availability may still have indirectly supported muscular performance in both groups. Carbohydrate intake contributes to glycogen restoration and energy availability, whereas proper hydration helps maintain cardiovascular function, thermoregulation, and neuromuscular efficiency during exercise. Pre vious position statements and sports nutrition guidelines indicate that carbohydrate-electrolyte beverages can reduce fatigue and support exercise capacity, particularly during repeated training sessions and prolonged physical activity. Coconut water additionally provides electrolytes, including potassium and sodium, which play important roles in neuromuscular transmission, muscle contraction, and fluid balance.
The absence of superiority of the modified isotonic beverage over coconut water alone may indicate that both beverages provided sufficient hydration support to maintain neuromuscular function during training. This interpretation is consistent with previous studies demonstrating that coconut water provides rehydration efficacy comparable to commercially available carbohydrate-electrolyte sports drinks. Therefore, while the modified beverage may have provided additional carbohydrates and energy, these advantages may not have been large enough to produce measurable improvements in abdominal muscle endurance during the relatively short intervention period.
Another possible explanation relates to the nature of the outcome measure itself. The sit-up test primarily assesses localized muscular endurance of the abdominal musculature rather than whole-body endurance performance. Previous validation studies have shown that sit-up performance is influenced by multiple factors, including motivation, technique, anthropometric characteristics, and training experience, which may reduce sensitivity for detecting subtle nutritional effects. Consequently, improvements attributable to enhanced hydration or energy availability may be more readily observed in aerobic performance indicators such as VO2max than in localized muscular endurance tests.
From a sports nutrition perspective, these findings suggest that the modified isotonic beverage may be more effective in supporting outcomes closely related to hydration status and aerobic performance than in directly enhancing muscular endurance. Since muscular endurance adaptations generally require longer-term neuromuscular and structural changes, future studies with extended intervention durations, larger sample sizes, and more comprehensive assessments of muscular performance may be necessary to determine whether modified isotonic beverages can exert meaningful effects on muscular endurance among adolescent athletes20,32,33.
Strengths and Limitations
This study has several important strengths. First, the randomized controlled trial design enhances internal validity and provides a robust framework for evaluating the causal effects of nutritional interventions on athlete performance outcomes. Randomization minimizes selection bias and improves comparability between groups, thereby strengthening confidence in the observed intervention effects. Second, adherence to beverage consumption was high throughout the study, reducing the likelihood that differences in compliance influenced the results. High acceptability of the intervention is particularly important in adolescent athletes because long-term effectiveness of nutritional strategies depends largely on adherence and practicality in real-world sporting environments.
Another strength is the simultaneous assessment of nutritional and performance-related outcomes. Previous studies evaluating coconut water and sports beverages have primarily focused on hydration status, fluid retention, or exercise performance separately. In contrast, the present study evaluated energy intake, aerobic capacity (VO2max), and abdominal muscle endurance concurrently, allowing a more comprehensive assessment of the potential physiological benefits of a natural isotonic beverage among adolescent soccer players. Furthermore, the intervention addressed an important knowledge gap regarding food-based sports beverages in youth athletes, a population that is particularly vulnerable to inadequate energy intake, low energy availability (LEA), and suboptimal hydration practices.
Despite these strengths, several limitations should be considered when interpreting the findings. First, the intervention period was relatively short (14 days), which may have limited the magnitude of physiological adaptations that could be achieved, particularly for muscular endurance outcomes. Improvements in aerobic fitness and neuromuscular performance often require longer periods of training and nutritional exposure to produce substantial adaptations. Consequently, the absence of significant between-group differences in abdominal muscle endurance may partially reflect insufficient intervention duration rather than a lack of physiological effect.
Second, the study was conducted in a single sports high school and included only male adolescent soccer players. Although this relatively homogeneous sample reduced variability and improved internal consistency, it may limit the generalizability of the findings to female athletes, athletes from other sports disciplines, or individuals from different age groups and training backgrounds. Nutritional requirements, hydration responses, and performance adaptations may vary according to sex, maturity status, sport characteristics, and training load.
Third, dietary intake was assessed using repeated 24-hour dietary recalls. Although this method is widely used in nutritional research, self-reported dietary assessment remains susceptible to recall bias, under-reporting, and day-to-day variability in food consumption. Such measurement error may have affected the precision of estimated energy intake values. In addition, standardized nutrition education was provided to both groups throughout the intervention and may have acted as a co-intervention, potentially influencing dietary intake independently of the modified isotonic beverage.
Another limitation relates to hydration assessment. Although the intervention was designed to improve hydration and energy availability, direct physiological indicators of hydration status, such as urine specific gravity, urine osmolality, plasma osmolality, or sweat loss, were not measured. Previous research has demonstrated that these biomarkers provide valuable insight into hydration responses and fluid balance during athletic activity. Inclusion of such measurements would have strengthened the mechanistic interpretation of the observed performance outcomes.
Finally, the study employed a single-blind design because the modified isotonic beverage was prepared daily from fresh mature coconut water, which has a limited shelf life and therefore required daily preparation and distribution. Under these conditions, implementing a full double-blind design was impractical and may have introduced a potential source of bias.
Future studies should include larger and more diverse athletic populations, longer intervention durations, and objective biomarkers of hydration and energy status, more objective dietary assessment methods, and double-blind designs where feasible. Additional investigations are also warranted to evaluate the effects of natural isotonic beverages on sport-specific performance, recovery, body composition, and long-term athlete health outcomes. Such research would further clarify the role of food-based hydration strategies in supporting athletic performance while reducing reliance on commercially manufactured sports drinks13,25,28.
Public Health and Practical Implications
The findings of this study have important implications for both sports nutrition practice and adolescent health. Adoles cence represents a critical period characterized by rapid growth, physiological maturation, and increased nutritional demands resulting from participation in organized sports. During this stage, adequate hydration and energy availability are essential not only for optimizing athletic performance but also for supporting normal growth, recovery, metabolic function, and long-term health outcomes.
The significant improvement in energy intake and aerobic capacity observed among participants receiving the modified isotonic beverage suggests that food-based hydration strategies may provide benefits beyond fluid replacement alone. Previous research has shown that adolescent athletes frequently fail to meet recommended nutritional requirements and often exhibit inadequate hydration practices, placing them at increased risk of low energy availability (LEA), impaired recovery, reduced training adaptation, and Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S). Consequently, nutritional interventions that simultaneously support hydration and energy intake may represent an effective approach to addressing multiple nutritional challenges commonly encountered in youth sports.
From a public health perspective, the use of a modified isotonic beverage formulated from mature coconut water, palm sugar, and sweet orange offers a promising example of a food-based and culturally relevant sports nutrition strategy. Unlike many commercially available sports drinks, the beverage utilizes locally available ingredients that are widely accessible in Indonesia and other tropical regions. Such an approach may improve affordability, accessibility, and acceptability while supporting sustainable dietary practices and reducing dependence on imported commercial sports products.
The findings also support broader efforts to promote healthy hydration behaviors among adolescent athletes. Previous studies have reported that a substantial proportion of young soccer players begin training or competition in a dehydrated state and often demonstrate insufficient knowledge regarding hydration practices. Because even mild dehydration may impair aerobic performance, cognitive function, thermoregulation, and exercise capacity, practical hydration interventions that can be readily implemented in school and sports settings may contribute to both performance enhancement and athlete well-being.
From a practical standpoint, the modified isotonic beverage may serve as a feasible nutritional option for coaches, sports nutritionists, schools, and youth sport development programs. The beverage can be incorporated into training and recovery routines as part of a broader sports nutrition strategy aimed at maintaining hydration, supporting energy availability, and promoting optimal athletic development. However, beverage consumption alone should not be considered sufficient to optimize performance. Effective athlete support requires an integrated approach that includes adequate dietary intake, nutrition education, hydration monitoring, individualized nutrition planning, and regular assessment of athlete health and training demands.
At the policy level, these findings provide preliminary evidence supporting the development of locally sourced sports nutrition interventions within school-based athletic programs. Such initiatives may contribute to healthier dietary behaviors, improved sports performance, and the prevention of nutrition-related problems among adolescent athletes while simultaneously promoting the utilization of locally available food resources.
Conclusions
Consumption of a modified isotonic beverage formulated from mature coconut water, sweet orange juice, and palm sugar for 15 days resulted in significantly greater improvements in energy intake and aerobic capacity (VO2max) compared with coconut water alone among adolescent soccer players. Although abdominal muscle endurance improved in both groups, no significant between-group difference was observed, indicating no clear advantage of the modified isotonic beverage over coconut water alone for this outcome. These findings suggest that a natural coconut water–based isotonic beverage may serve as a practical nutritional strategy to support energy adequacy and aerobic fitness in adolescent athletes. Further studies with larger sample sizes, longer intervention periods, direct assessment of hydration status, and strategies to minimize the potential influence of dietary recall bias and co-interventions such as nutrition education are warranted to confirm these findings and explore the underlying physiological mechanisms.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge the Specialized Sports High School of South Sulawesi Province (SMANKO), Indonesia, for granting permission and providing facilities for this research. Special thanks are extended to the coaches, teachers, and administrative personnel for their assistance during participant recruitment, data collection, and intervention monitoring. The authors also sincerely thank all adolescent soccer athletes who participated in this study for their cooperation and dedication.
The authors further acknowledge the Faculty of Public Health, Hasanuddin University, Indonesia, for providing academic supervision and research support throughout the completion of this study.
References
Explorar
Artículos
Volúmenes
Sobre la revista
Más leídos
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria
Nutrición Clínica y Dietética Hospitalaria